How can you turn a guy friend with benefits into a boyfriend when you both agree that you are compatible

  Improve

Answer

Tell him that you really enjoy being with him and that you would like to date him. Ask him out.

Answer

In my opinion you need to talk to him and let him know that you would like him to be something more than a friend with benefits. that happened to me and now my friend with benefits is my boyfriend. GOOD LUCK...

Answer

Just be honest and open. In relationships, ALWAYS be honest and open. Tell him how you feel. That's it.

Answer

Stop being a friend with benefits.

Answer

If the benefits include sex, and you're the one who brought up compatibility, he's either looking for someone who's more than just compatible (then your chances are rather low, at least short-term; if he still doesn't find someone in, say, 2 years, you may be able to convince him to take you) or he's not looking at all.